Tuesday, November 20, 2007

Even More Disturbing - Women's Issue

A Saudi Arabian human rights attorney is asking the government to allow him to represent a woman who was gang-raped -- and then sentenced to prison for speaking out about the case.

The attorney, Abdulrahman al-Lahim, had his license revoked last week by a judge for speaking to the Saudi-controlled media about the case, al-Lahim told CNN. The judge more than doubled the sentence against al-Lahim's 19-year-old client because she spoke to the media about the case, a court source told Arab News, an English-language Middle Eastern daily newspaper.
The woman -- who was initially sentenced in October 2006 to 90 lashes -- had her sentenced increased to 200 lashes and was ordered to serve six months in prison under Saudi Arabia's strict Islamic law.

"We were shocked," al-Lahim said of the increased sentence. CNN has been unable to reach Saudi government officials for comment on this report, despite repeated requests. Watch the emotional toll the crime took on the rape victim »

Al-Lahim had petitioned the court to sentence the attackers to the death penalty, but instead the court agreed to increase their jail sentences, which had been two to three years, to two to nine years, al-Lahim said. The case has sparked outrage among human rights groups.

"Barring the lawyer from representing the victim in court is almost equivalent to the rape crime itself," said Fawzeyah al-Oyouni, founding member of the newly formed Saudi Association for the Defense of Women's Rights. "This is not just about the girl, it's about every woman in Saudi Arabia," she said. "We're fearing for our lives and the lives of our sisters and our daughters and every Saudi woman out there. We're afraid of going out in the streets."

Human Rights Watch said it has called on Saudi Arabia's King Abdullah "to immediely void the verdict and drop all charges against the rape victim and to order the court to end its harassment of her lawyer."

The woman, who is married, and an unrelated man were abducted and she was raped by a group of seven men more than a year ago, the lawyer said. The male victim was also given an increased sentence of 200 lashes and six months in prison, al-Lahim said.

The man and woman were attacked after they met so she could retrieve an old photograph of herself from him, according to al-Lahim. Citing phone records from the police investigation, al-Lahim said the man was trying to blackmail his client. He noted the photo she was trying to retrieve was harmless and did not show his client in any compromising position.

Al-Lahim said the man tried to blame his client for insisting on meeting him that day. It is illegal for a woman to meet with an unrelated male under Saudi's Islamic law. Al-Lahim has been ordered to attend a disciplinary hearing at the Ministry of Justice next month, where he faces a possible three-year suspension and disbarment, according to Human Rights Watch.

He told CNN he has appealed to the Ministry of Justice to reinstate his law license and plans to meet with Justice Minister Abdullah bin Muhammad bin Ibrahim Al Al-Sheikh. "Currently she doesn't have a lawyer, and I feel they're doing this to isolate her and deprive her from her basic rights," he said. "We will not accept this judgment and I'll do my best to continue representing her because justice needs to take place."

He said the handling of the case is a direct contradiction of judicial reforms announced by the Saudi king earlier this month. "The Ministry of Justice needs to have a very clear standing regarding this case because I consider this decision to be judiciary mutiny against the reform that King Abdullah bin Abdulaziz started and against Saudi women who are being victimized because of such decisions," he said.

Saudi Arabia's Islamic law or sharia is not written and, therefore, subject to a wide array of interpretations. Human Rights Watch points out that a judge in Jeddah threw out a lawyer simply because he was a member of the Ismaili faith, a branch of Shia Islam.

Under Saudi law, women are subject to numerous restrictions, including a strict dress code, a prohibition against driving and a requirement that they get a man's permission to travel or have surgery. Women are also not allowed to testify in court unless it is about a private matter that was not observed by a man, and they are not allowed to vote.

The Saudi government recently has taken some steps toward bettering the situation of women in the kingdom, including the establishment earlier this year of special courts to handle domestic abuse cases, adoption of a new labor law that addresses working women's rights and creation of a human rights commission.

Christoph Wilcke of Human Rights Watch praised the female rape victim and her attorney for speaking out about the case, which he said may be indicative of "many injustices that we still don't know about." "It's not only one court, it is the Saudi government that is fully behind punishing a woman who's been raped [and] punishing the lawyer who's trying to help her and doing that both because they've spoken to the media," Wilcke told CNN. "And if they hadn't spoken to the media, we wouldn't know about it."

Shying away from criticism of key ally, State Department spokesman Sean McCormack called the case and the punishment "surprising" and "astonishing."

"While this is a judicial procedure -- part of a judicial procedure -- overseas in courts outside of our country, still while it is very difficult to offer any detailed comment about this situation, I think most people would be quite astonished by the situation, " McCormack said. "I can't get involved in specific court cases in Saudi Arabia dealing with its own citizens. But most people here would be quite surprised to learn of the circumstances and then the punishment meted out," he said.

I read articles like this and i get so so angry. How on earth can a victim of a heinous crime like rape end up being punished? And this is the case around the world. If it isnt actual physical punishment, the jibes that come from police and so called concerned partners force women around the world to hide and say nothing. Living in silence. When i studied criminal law, there were countless cases of the humilation meted out to victims of rape - fast forward to the elective i chose - Sex & Gender in the Legal Process and more and more stories came to my attention.

In the real world, the injustice and inhumane treatment meted out to women make me so so angry. So angry that i want to cry. All these man-made laws, men ruled societies that do their best to kill the spirits of women.....Dont get me wrong, men are great. But here's the thing, its clear that some men perceive women as threats, or consider them to be less human than they are so bad treatment, thwarting of rights are enforced. Well, for me, i refuse, absolutely refuse to take it lying down.

I am not a bra burning feminist, but i realise that doing nothing is something that all women must be ashamed of. I urge you all, men and women to do something. It can be simple words of encouragement to the girls and women around you - letting them know that they worth more than gold; it can be buying a book for a girl child; or sponsoring a a girl child; or teaching your sons and brothers to treat women with respect; teaching the men in your lives to take care of themselves and not to look at women as toys, playthings or maids.....

I know a lot of Nigerian women doing their best to change the world in their way. And i am not talking about the famous ones. I am talking about wonderful women like Onada the blogger, Mrs Amuta (my mother), Hanney Musawa, Mariam & Zainab M and so so many more in my life that are doing things that are changing the lives of girls. These girls will grow up more empowered and able to stand firmer on their feet.

Knowledge is power. I urge you all to please put the women in your lives in the positions of all the victims that we hear and read about and use the ensuing emotions you feel to do some thing.

Much Love!


Tiger Tem said...

Sounds like we did the same electives in law.

The Islamic law is a very very difficult thing to understand. I abhor the way they treat women and even though I've enjoyed my trips to Dubai....you can still see it there. Within reason I try to respect it as its not my culture and I think we all need to respect each others cultures but my problem with Islamic law is the way its often misintepreted to completely violate human rights. That's not what it was intended to do.

Society is so patriarchal and its something that comes out in so many various guises. The whole body facism is something I spoke about on my blog...its a form of controlling women and making women feel bad about themselves so ultimately they're easier to control. There are many billion dollar industries based on this. Clothing, beauty, media...yes I'm simplifying it a little.....but not that much.

I agree that everybody needs to reach out to the women in their lief and make sure they know they're exceptional. Just the way they are.

What's the equivalent of misogyny for women? Feminism? We don't even get a word!!!

Adora said...

It would amaze you to know that i know quite a lot about this.
Some time in 2000, i stumbled on a book written by a Jordian woman exciled in the UK. she escaped from Jordan after her friend was killed by her father and brothers because she was susupected to have been dating a british soldier posted to Jordan. Trust me, you dont want to hear the gory details of how she was murdered. I call it murder cos in all honesty, thats what it is.
But their system calls it "Honour Killing". This law permits any male to kill a female suspected to have any dealings (whether intimate relationship or otherwise) with an unrelated male. This malicious act has been on for ages and is still in existence till this very day. Their government tends to exonorates itself from this and looks the other way while this violation of human rights takes place.
Its so sad, it really eats me out! what is most annoying is that these men now take advantage of the situation by assaulting, raping and abusing the women. But there is little the women can do because they run the risk of being missunderstood and eventually get killed!
you can only imagine how it feels to live in this bondage of slavery, intimidation and gendercide.
Many have written, protested and even lost their lives in trying to fight this unjust cause but to no avail. But that should not deter our efforts. We should continously bring this evil to bear and hope that one day, the change will come.

LondonBuki said...

Terrible - I read about a girl who came to live in the UK and was raped by 2 men while a woman looked on - Her family in her country(I can't remember where in Africa) are looking for her to kill her because she brought shame upon her family by telling the police about it... HER FAMILY!

I am not saying it's right for people unrelated to the victim to treat her the way they are but it's even worse when it's their family... all in the name of "honour".

There are terrible things going on in the world around us...

Soul said...

This came across my desk a few weeks ago and I unfortunately was not surprised.
Again I have no words. I just don't.
I can't comprehend something so heinous.

Things just seem to be getting more and more heinous.
I'm sorry Uzo. But i don't have any words right now. I just don't.

Daddy's Girl said...

Very disturbing, disgusting, heart-breaking, so horribly wrong in so many ways. Yet this terrible injustice continues in our world. You are right about the fact that we all have to do something - to be honest, sometimes I feel like it's all just a drop in an ever-increasing ocean, but it does count... and whatever we might be doing at the moment, we all need to be doing more...

Patrice said...

Just when I thought I had heard it all. disgusting!

@tiger tem - the equivalent of misogyny for women is misandry. Not surprisingly, it is a somewhat obscure term. If such a word in Arabic even exists, I expect that it would be against the law to speak it or include it in the dictionary.

Yuddie said...

That's why our lives can not be consumed by what we'll wear to the next party or if we'll get an invite for that popular person's birthday cruise... or any other thing that does not matter in the grand scheme of things. We can't live like that... we just can't. There's so much to fight for... so much to stand up for... so much to speak against... so much to dedicate our time and efforts towards changing. Whether it be children's issues (oh don't get me started on that one) or women's issues, or political issues. We MUST do something. We MUST be a part of change. We all pray it doesn't hit close to home but it is only a matter of time before we are confronted with it in our backyards. Let's not wait for that time to come to start doing something about the evil that plagues our world.

Bella Naija said...

Yeah I TRIED to read an article on the same issue same days ago but couldnt.
Things like this get to me in such a deep way that I cant even explain it.
I still cant belive that we are in 2007/2008 and some women are still suffering this way....
It hurts so bad!
The worst part is that I just dont believe that things will change significantly in the future. With countries like Saudi, the international community is never going to put significant pressure on them to change their laws. After all, they are still a major oil supplier. Despite all their human rights abuses, didnt Queen E just roll out the red carpet for the Saudi Royal family?
But I guess we all just have to do our bit.
I think it starts with all of us?
The root of the problem even beyond the law is why a group of young men decided to force themselves on an innocent young lady?
As women, we have to start with our sons and raise them well. Teach them to respect women etc...I dont even know what to say. I pray for some sort of healing for the young lady and many others who this (and worse) has happened to.

Pix Gremlin (akin) said...

Osi baba'n'la Nonsense! London Buki, i too have read the same story that you wrote about. The missus tends to give me all the case studies that she goes through and it's just disgusting. And what's worse is that under the guise of religion and being pious, people will abuse others.


Sexual assault is terrible! It breaks my heart to hear stories of sexual assault and pedophilia. As I recently wrote we need to be vigilant. We must protect victims, potential victims and ensure that criminals get the punishment they deserve.

And to think that the Bush administration could only refer to the Saudi incident as "astounding". Sadly...

Noni Moss said...

What more can I say? The only thing I can take from this other than the desolation and sadness is that there are charities and people out there fighting for women's rights, and lamenting their plights.

Zahratique said...

Yeah I came across this story some days ago and it is indeed disturbing.

@ TIger tem, this isnt Islamic law you know. I think the khalwa has to do with their middle eastern culture not islam (of course they try to justify everything they do with religion) I dont recall ever reading laws like that in Quran or even hadith. These people *shakes head*